A scouts perspective

A scouts perspective

Thursday, April 27, 2017

2017 NFL Draft Reports - Tight Ends

TIGHT ENDS

O.J. Howard, Alabama, #88

Game Film Evaluated:
Kent State (2016)
Texas A&M (2016)
Auburn (2016)

Summary:  Elite athlete and ideal for the position.  He has the frame to outmatch any defender, faster than most cornerbacks and hands like a wide receiver who can block effectively. He has plus footwork to block but lacks strength at the POA to maul defenders off the line. He keeps his feet moving effectively especially in pass protection, he has the feet of an offensive tackle. He can turn the defenders and seal off the edge on run plays.  He has excellent burst off the snap to explode into the secondary and very smooth receiver. He is not a polished receiver, does not have a feel for setting up defenders and running crisp routes. He does not drop passes, he can make the difficult catch and even in traffic. He would of had far more catches had the QB play been better. OJ Howard is the most talented tight end in the class but he has to master the little things for the position as a receiver to take his game to the elite level it should be.  His blocking technique is solid but could use to add some strength to make him a plus blocker in the run game. He is plenty talented enough to get open on his athleticism alone but there is a learning curve to set up defenders and tighten his route running. Late 1st round grade.

Evan Engram, Ole Miss, #17

Game Film Evaluated:
Georgia (2016)
Auburn (2016)
Florida State (2016)

Summary: Impressive high point the ball. Seems to have one bad drop per game especially those away from his body. Inconsistent catcher in traffic, he did not make a lot of catches in traffic and struggled to shield defenders away from the ball. He can bust the seams beating the linebacker and safety to the gap in the middle of the field. He gives effort as a blocker but doesn’t have the bulk, length or feet to be anything more than a below average blocker. He is a physical runner, consistently gains a yard or two after contact. He can move effectively, get in and out of breaks effectively. Not a polished route runner but didn’t have to be in college. He is not explosive as other undersized tight ends such as Jimmy Graham or Vernon Davis. Evan Engram is a solid receiving tight end option who needs to go to a team that doesn’t run the ball a whole lot and likes to pass the ball often out of shotgun and likes to split their tight ends out wide. The Colts offense is a perfect fit for a player like Engram. He will never be a complete tight end nor an elite athletic tight end receiving threat but he will get catches, become a safety valve although he needs to improve his route running to get open vs athletic safeties and backers who can keep up with him. He is a dangerous weapon if he matches up against a backer in space, he will always win that match up. 4th round grade.

Jordan Leggett, Clemson, #16

Game Film Evaluated:
Virginia Tech (2016)
Florida State (2016)
Alabama (2016)

Summary: Poor blocker, very little strength at the POA, does not keep feet moving once engaged. He is athletic and someone who can beat the seams effectively. He has good feel for getting a clean release at the line, able to set up defenders when running downfield. He can make the difficult catch and in traffic. However he will have the occasional drop and then make a spectacular catch. Jordan Leggett is a receiving tight end only who can get open running adequate routes, able to set up defenders, use his hands to get a clean release. He can make tough catches in traffic, even a great catch but suffers from the occasional drop. He needs to improve his blocking to at least average so he can be a full time starter but someone who can get open split out wide and from the in line position. Early 3rd round grade.

Jake Butt, Michigan, #88

Game Film Evaluated:
Ohio State (2016)
Utah (2015)
Indiana (2015)

Summary: Excellent frame, above average blocker. He shows good effort in the blocking game. He has adequate feet and knows how to use them in pass protection. He has adequate athleticism and can get downfield at times. He will struggle to create separation until he improves his route running. He slows down a lot when getting it and out of breaks which is why he rounds off a lot of routes. Adequate safety valve as a receiving threat and he is capable of busting the seams and making catches in the mid area of the defense. Jake Butt is a complete tight end prospect who can assist in pass protection, run blocking from the inside position, make underneath catches and stretch the seams of the defense. However he is not a polished route runner nor a strong blocker, just adequate at this point. I have concerns whether he will be able to create separation when running intermediate routes at the next level, he would be a fine backup tight end for a team that uses a lot of double tight end sets like the Cowboys and Patriots. 4th round grade.

Adam Shaheen, Ashland, #44

Game Film Evaluated:
Wayne State (2016)
Northwood (2016)

Summary: Very big body but moves extremely well. He is fluid and can turn pretty quickly. Not a good route runner at this point, not someone who is comfortable with getting a clean release and beating a press. Doesn’t position himself well against smaller defenders to win contested passes. He dropped a pass that was catchable when he tried to go above his head. He has an extra gear and definite long strider. Very strong hands and quick feet, good footwork in blocking. He can seal off the edge and block comfortable at the second level. His pass blocking is better than run blocking. He lined up a lot in traditional inline positions. Long arms and uses them well when blocking. He can make the difficult catch but did not see contested catches. Adam Shaheen is a interesting prospect with excellent size, frame and length for the position with added athleticism to be a above average receiving option. He brings a traditional tight end playing style who is comfortable blocking on the line of scrimmage, handling linebackers and lineman effectively with strength and footwork. He needs to improve his route running, able to position himself well against defenders in tight spaces to make tough catches. He has speed to become a difficult match up assuming he improves his positioning. The level of competition is poor but his game translates well to the NFL, he just needs to do the little things to maximize that talent he has to become a legit starter in the NFL for a team that uses a inline TE as a balanced blocker and receiver who will run downfield and bust the seams of a defense. Late 3rd round grade.

David Njoku, Miami (FL), #86

Game Film Evaluated:
Pittsburgh (2016)
West Virginia (2016)
Virginia (2016)

Summary: Below average run blocker, good feet and understands footwork. He has long arms and needs to add strength to be at least an average blocker. Shows good feel for route running, crisp in and out of his breaks. He can work his way open for the QB when the play breaks down. Plus athleticism and able to stretch the field vertically to the seams. Positions himself well from the defender and makes the tough catches in traffic. Absolute beast in the redzone. Drops too many passes, perhaps just loses concentration or trying to run before securing the catch but happens too much. Physical blocker, likes to finish his blocks and take his guy to the whistle. David Njoku is one of the most advanced receiving tight end options in the class. He runs like a receiver with the size of a tight end and is a physical runner after the catch. He absolutely destroys the defender near the endzone, safeties wont be able to stick nor linebackers, they will have to dedicate a corner to him with size near the goaline. He has the upside to be a better blocker but he isnt even average yet. He has the mindset and frame with length, just needs to play with stronger hands to keep his man engaged and use his already solid footwork to neutralize his man. There is a lot to like with his game and it all translates well to the next level. He should be one of the top tight ends in the game very soon and if he continues to work on his blocking, one of the more complete tight ends. He has first round receiving ability but falls to the 2nd round grade since his game is not complete yet.

Michael Roberts, Toledo, #80

Game Film Evaluated:
App State (2016)

Summary: Ideal frame with long arms and carries his weight well. He moves very well for his size, he can get upfield effectively, can bust the seams downfield, gets up to speed quickly and get out of breaks well. He is not a comfortable route runner, able to set up defenders or recognize coverage. He shows a feel for getting a clean release at the line. He has good strength and needs to improve his technique in the blocking game but the feet, length and strength is there to project him well. He is a potential player and needs a year or two before he can be a full time contributor but the ability is there. Michael Roberts has the skills to project him to starting material as a athletic tight end option who can block, stretch the field and become a strong safety valve working underneath. He needs to improve route running, learn technique as a blocker. He might really be something by year 3 in the right situation, someone who would really benefit being a backup learning from a veteran and then become an impact player. 4th round grade with significant potential.

Gerald Everett, South Alabama, #12

Game Film Evaluated:
Georgia Southern (2016)
North Carolina State (2015)

Summary: Plus athlete, he looks like a wide receiver in a tight ends body. He moves as fluid as a receiver, he can run downfield with ease with good speed. He can adjust to poorly thrown balls, very good balance able to break tackles and keeps moving after contact. Poor blocker. He can make the difficult catch in traffic. Extremely limited route tree in college. Gerald Everett is another in a long line of former basketball players who attempt to become football players at the tight end position. He possesses all the tools to be a plus receiving tight end who can split out wide and beat virtually any defender in man coverage. He looks a lot like Jimmy Graham with just as much improvement needed as a blocker, he will get beaten consistently in the run game but he can contribute quickly as a receiver. However he is not a polished receiver, he lets defenders cross his face and get between him and the QB. He has got to improve his route running but he has the athleticism to get open on talent against backers and safeties. He can make a team as a 3rd tight end who can split out wide and still get open in space. There is high potential with him but lot of improvement to be made as well. He is more talented than other undersized tight ends in the class but has a lot of room to grow in the rest of his game. Early 4th round grade.

Bucky Hodges, Virginia Tech, #7

Game Film Evaluated:
Tennessee (2016)
Pittsburgh (2016)
Boston College (2016)


Summary: Athletic wide receiving in a tight ends body. He moves well and has speed to be utilized in a variety of ways. He was used on speed options as a back and sent on go routes on the perimeter to make plays downfield. He saw very very little time as a traditional tight end inline and busting seams, running routes in the middle of the field. He was much more like a slot receiver who is a below average blocker. Virtually no experience as a inline tight end with his hand on the ground able to run routes. Bucky Hodges is a project player who needs to learn how to play the position as a tight end instead of a wide receiver. He ran only a few routes in college and did not seem to have to read the coverage and make adjustments on the same page as the QB. He projects best to teams that don’t mind poor blocking tight ends and rather just focus on their receiving ability. However Hodges is not a polished receiver nor does he play like a basketball player able to position himself well against defenders. 5th round grade.

2017 NFL Draft Reports - Wide Receivers

WIDE RECEIVERS

Corey Davis, Western Michigan, #84

Game Film Evaluated:
Wisconsin (2016)
Toledo (2016)
Central Michigan (2016)

Summary: Very poor ball security, he puts it in one hand away from his body after he catches the ball. He shows good feel for getting off press coverage and running routes. He is a physical receiver and will fight for the ball. Plus run after catch ability, he will break tackles with a stiff arm, quickness or ability to stop and start again with speed. He is a good route runner and comfortable running routes from the inside and outside positions. Inconsistent hands. There are questions about him coming down with the difficult catch and in traffic. Trash talker with the defense. Corey Davis is a big physical receiver who runs good routes and elite after the catch. One defender will never bring him down on his own in space. He did not play with good leaping ability nor someone who showed ability to go up and get the ball at its highest point. He is a very good but not elite receiver prospect. He is a starter in the NFL and likely a #1 but he isn’t perfect. He is a receiver defenses will be afraid of when it comes to blitzing because they fear his ability after the catch to turn a short catch into a score. Definite first round grade but not elite.

Mike Williams, Clemson #7

Game Film Evaluated:
Ohio State (2016)
Alabama (2016)
Florida State (2016)
Summary: Very good possession type receiver. Very good with his hands to get a good release at the line. One of the best in the country at making catches in traffic and coming down with the spectacular catch. Not an explosive speed deep threat. He is a fluid receiver and this helps him get up to speed quickly. Mike Williams could be a #1 receiver but not for an offense that wants to take a lot of deep shots. He is a supremely efficient strong physical possession receiver who can out muscle and position himself to make a catch and help out his QB. He excels at making the difficult catch and coming up with it in traffic. He is comfortable using his hands to get a clean release and shows a good feel for running routes but again was not used as a downfield threat. He will not be a burner type of receiver, he will struggle to get over the top of defenses except on double moves. Similar player to Dez Bryant. First round grade and a day one starter granted he goes to an offense that doesn’t try to use him on go routes and lots of downfield options. He will be a machine working underneath and on the intermediate routes. He will disappoint if you expect him to make lots of deep catches.

Isaiah Ford, Virginia Tech, #1

Game Film Evaluated:
Tennessee (2016)
Pittsburgh (2016)
Boston College (2016)

Summary: Plus route runner, quick in and out of his breaks. Not a burner, will struggle to gain separation on go routes. Average hands, he will struggle to make the difficult catch especially away from his body. He is very good on the back shoulder pass, adjusting his body and making the play which projects well. He can high point the ball and has good body control. He has good quickness, able to set up defenders and gain separation on intermediate routes due to his smooth route running. He locates the ball in the air and adjust to it well. Isaiah Ford is a good receiver but his hands and lack of deep speed limit his potential at the next level. He looks like a good number 2 receiver who can get open on the outside and inside. He will create separation in man coverage thanks to his route running but will not be able to run away and get over the top of defenses. He is a dangerous match up near the goaline as he can get inside leverage, adjust to the back shoulder and high point the ball on the fade. I don’t see number one receiver potential but he is best suited for an offense that wants to nickel and dime defenses or already has a plus deep threat. 2nd round grade.

Ryan Switzer, North Carolina, #3

Game Film Evaluated:
Pittsburgh (2016)
Florida State (2016)
North Carolina State (2016)

Summary: Quick and fast slot receiver type. He can get in and out of breaks with top speed. He can make plays downfield and bust up the middle of a defense. He played exclusively out of the slot on the games observed. He has long speed and he can adjust to make the difficult catch. Very good hands who can haul it in away from his body. Ryan Switzer is a plus slot receiver prospect who can make plays underneath and also take advantage of defenders jumping his underneath stuff to bust the seams of a defense. He can recognize coverage and shows ability to run option routes. He is not physical in blocking nor someone who can handle defenders who try to muscle him off his routes. He only played in the slot in college but he might be able to line up on the outside and use his quickness to shake defenders. At worst he is a solid slot receiver who can make become a 3rd down machine to keep the chains moving. 4th round grade.

John Ross, Washington, #1

Game Film Evaluated:
Stanford (2016)
USC (2016)
Colorado (2016)

Summary: Does not work back to the QB if his route does not get him open. Not a security blanket for his QB. He fails to locate the ball quickly and adjust to it in the air. Raw ability, he has plus speed and can run away from defenders. Kickoff returner. Does not look to fight for the ball, not someone who is going to try and go up to high point the ball and make a contested catch. He depends on the flag to come out instead of trying to make the play. He needs to try to make the play and not just count on the flag to come out. Sometimes looks mentally disengaged hanging his head low reminding me of Martellus Bennett when he came out of A&M. John Ross has tremendous athleticism but he is not a good football player at this point. He has poor football awareness, doesn’t know how to help out his QB to make himself open. He doesn’t fight for the ball in the air nor able to locate it quickly to make the tough catch. He drops catchable passes and just so much of his game is a turn off. He is a developmental project with legit speed to get over the top of defenses but he is not close to matching production with potential. 5th round grade.

JuJu Smith-Schuster, USC, #9

Game Film Evaluated:
Washington (2016)
Arizona (2016)
Penn State (2016)

Summary: He knows how to get open, make tough catches in tight spaces. Strong underneath and intermediate option. Good blocker. Aware of the holes in zone coverage and just sits there waiting for his QB to find him. He is a smooth runner, he has a burst and can gain separation as a result. He fails to come up with contested catches at too high a rate, needs to box out defenders so he can make contested catches that fell incomplete in college. Emotional player that can get the better of him at times if he gets frustrated. He is able to break tackles and has good speed to run away for the score. JuJu Smith-Schuster is a solid versatile receiver who does everything well but nothing is elite. He has good frame, enough speed and adequate hands. He blocks well and is smart on the field to find the soft spots and get open for his QB. He is able to make plays downfield and on the shorter routes. He needs to improve his route running for him to gain separation as a solid possession type receiver. Late 2nd round grade.

Dede Westbrook, Oklahoma, #11

Game Film Evaluated:
Ohio State (2016)
Texas (2016)
Kansas State (2016)

Summary: Excellent speed and explosive receiver type. He can get to full speed quickly, catches passes at all levels of the field. He was used on speed options, screens, posts and go routes. Good hands but asking a bit much to come down with a spectacular catch. He is capable of taking a catch the distance if he gets a seam. Not a polished route runner, needs to get more comfortable finding holes in zone coverage. Dede Westbrook is a taller receiver prospect with legit long speed who can make plays at all levels but needs to become a more polished receiver. Similar skill set to Terrence Williams but a bit faster. He would be a tremendous 3rd receiver who can play outside and inside. He might never be the guy type option at receiver core but he is a more than capable number two receiver who has speed to stretch the defense. He projects to have more upside than just a one trick speed receiver but that is his impact initially in the NFL. Early 3rd round grade.

Chris Godwin, Penn State, #12

Game Film Evaluated:
Michigan (2016)
USC (2016)
Iowa (2016)

Summary: Good frame and has maxed out weight he can carry well. He moves well but not a burner or explosive type receiver. He gets physical with his hands and doesn’t mind mixing it up with corners. Excels at making the difficult catch, spectacular catch, catch in traffic and contested catches from the defender and still coming down with it. Adjust well to it in the air and has supreme body control. He has good feel for getting a clean release at the line and adequate blocker. He ran a lot of go routes on the perimeter but that is not his game at the next level. He is a productive possession type receiver who can win jump balls against smaller defenders and he is a receiver that will make his QB better making bad throws into completions. He does not need it on the number to come down with it. Chris Godwin is a very good receiver who doesn’t need separation to get catches in the NFL, he has got to earn the trust of his QB or else they won’t look his way since there won’t be much space to fit the ball into. Reminds me of Anquan Boldin. 2nd round grade.

Josh Reynolds, Texas A&M, #11

Game Film Evaluated:
South Carolina (2016)
LSU (2016)
Arkansas (2016)

Summary: Taller frame than most and has a high center of gravity. Looks like former Texas receiver Roy Williams with long arms too. He can fly up the field and can make some athletic catches but he also will drop the easy one without any contact. He is a bit of a one trick pony since he isn’t someone who will run good routes since he powers down a lot going in and out of his routes. He can add speed to a wide receiver group but likely never a full time starter in the NFL. He needs to learn how to read coverages, find soft spots and use that frame to make catches in the intermediate areas. If he doesn’t, QBs won’t look his way unless it is a downfield route. Josh Reynolds has legit speed with good size but he’s not someone who looks like a regular starter who can make plays at all levels of the defense able to run a full route tree. He can carve out a niche in the NFL but the kid has to work hard to earn it.  5th round grade.

ArDarius Stewart, Alabama, #13

Game Film Evaluated:
USC (2016)
Mississippi State (2016)
Auburn (2016)

Summary: Tremendous athlete, top notch speed. Good leaping ability, he can turn any catch into a score. The QB play at Alabama hurt his stats and ability to make an impact on the field. He needs to improve his on field body language, sometimes shows up the QB if throw doesn’t go his way. Raw player, not refined technique to get off press, feel for running lots of routes, setting up defenders and finding holes in coverage. AfDarius Stewart is going to be drafted higher than he produces on the field due to potential and the poor QB play in college. He will need a year to learn to run a full route tree, understand coverages and get a clean release off the line before he can really become a regular contributor offensively. His upside is legit and has for sure #1 receiver stuff. He needs to work hard in the film room and practices to become a professional well rounded player. 3rd round grade on production but he’s got no doubt first round talent.

Chad Hansen, California, #6

Game Film Evaluated:
Texas (2016)
Stanford (2016)
Arizona State (2016)

Summary: Good size and frame for the position, able to play on the line of scrimmage and get off press coverage. Very comfortable getting a clean release off the line, uses his hands well. Has some quickness and gets to top speed quickly. Limited long speed, gaining separation will be difficult at the next level. Fairly limited route tree in college, slants, , screens, go and stop routes. Need to see how he will run come backs, out routes and inside routes which will determine his ability to gain separation. Elite leaping ability to go up and win jump balls, good body control to adjust to a poorly thrown ball and win those contested passes. Chad Hansen is a very good college receiver but his lack of long speed and route running could cause some issues getting catches at the next level. He looks like a solid possession receiver for a team that doesn’t want to test defenses downfield often or to line up across from a burner. 3rd round grade.

Zay Jones, East Carolina, #7

Game Film Evaluated:
Virginia Tech (2016)
Cincinnati (2016)
South Florida (2016)
South Carolina (2016)

Summary: Smooth receiver who makes good cuts to get open. He is comfortable to make the tough catch in traffic and has strong hands. He can line up outside and in the slot to run short to intermediate routes. He is not a deep threat, he lacks the extra gear to get behind defenses. He is not a good option for crossing routes or speed routes as he just doesn’t have that gear on the field. He can beat press coverage and has good release. He can drive defenders upfield and work back to the QB shielding the defender away from the ball. Above average run blocker in the run game, has long arms and uses them well. He looks a bit thin in the lower body. Zay Jones has limited ceiling but he has a high floor as he will be ready to contribute in the NFL as a rookie. He can do all the little things to make up for the limited speed, strong hands, good route runner and should earn the trust of his QB to throw the ball in small areas. He would be a fine possession receiver alongside a top deep threat but should not be looked at as a quick slot receiver option. Jones projects as a outside receiver who can contribute and be a reliable option from the late 3rd to early 4th round.

Cooper Kupp, Eastern Washington, #10

Game Film Evaluated:
Washington State (2016)
Oregon (2015)
Richmond (2016)

Summary: Ideal frame for the position, tall and strong frame. He carries the weight well and has excellent burst off the line and very explosive receiver. He has legit downfield speed and can out run defenders in space. Very limited route tree lining up mostly out of the slot and running downfield go routes against a safety. He has good feel for running routes but there will be a learning curve as he expands his route tree at the next level. Very strong and he will look to punish defenders who try to tackle him up high, he will win that match up and then out run them to the endzone. Elite production in college but he is not a product receiver, there is legit pro potential. Did not see any press coverage in the games observed. Cooper Kupp accomplished all he could do in college, no other receivers came close to the production he had in school. He has the size, speed, strength and hands to be a very good receiver in the NFL. He will have a learning curve with getting off press coverage and expanding the route tree which might limit him as a rookie but he will become a impact receiver. He could be a #1 receiver in the NFL but he needs half a season to add the tools to become the total package. Second round grade.

Carlos Henderson, Louisiana Tech, #1

Game Film Evaluated:
Texas Tech (2016)
Navy (2016)
Western Kentucky (2016)

Summary: Electric runner after the catch, one defender will not bring him down. He can stop on a dime and get to full speed quickly. Willing returner. Not a strong receiver, a body catcher and struggles to make the catch in traffic. He has good speed to get on top of a defense. He can break tackles as a balanced runner. He is a capable receiver, able to make the back shoulder catch at the goaline. Average route runner. Carlos Henderson is a solid receiving prospect, he has legit run after catch ability that translates well to the NFL and he can be a solid receiving option. He is a capable receiver to make plays from the slot and outside position. He is not a strong route runner nor someone who will make the contested catch in traffic consistently or comfortable getting off press coverage. At worst he is a sub package receiver who will return kicks but he could work to become a regular offensive contributor as a number 2 receiver and make impact plays especially after the catch. 3rd round grade.

Shelton Gibson, West Virginia, #1

Game Film Evaluated:
Youngstown State (2016)


Summary: Tall slender frame with an extra gear in the open field. He can get over the top of the defense and tracks the ball well over his shoulder to make the catch. Poor route runner, he rounds the corners and doesn’t have a feel for finding the open spots in coverage. He doesn’t work his way back to the QB when the play breaks down. He is a willing returner but not a dynamic returner. Shelton Gibson has the speed to earn a spot on a team and is a willing returner who can earn a job in the NFL.  As a receiver, he needs to improve his ability to get off press coverage and run tighter routes but he is a backup speed receiver at this point. 5th round grade.

2017 NFL Draft Reports - Runningbacks

RUNNINGBACKS

Dalvin Cook. Florida State, #4

Game Film Evaluated:
Florida (2016)
Clemson (2016)
Michigan (2016)

Summary: Excellent agility to get ouf of tackles. Good hands out of the backfield to even make the difficult catch. Runs with tremendous balance to get out of tackles, plus juke moves. He doesn’t run to daylight and will run up the backside of his teammates following the play. Good burst and has the long speed to run away from a defense. He takes a bit too many hard hits and needs to run lower to the ground and avoid those hits. Dalvin Cook is a complete back and has been a workhorse back in college. He can carry the ball inside and outside effectively with the home run threat and can catch the ball effectively although not a good route runner in the class of Joe Mixon or McCaffrey. Cook is a more agile version of Zeke Elliott but he is not close to the class of pass protector was coming out of Ohio State. Cook is a solid player, not an elite level prospect especially since his threat as a receiver isn’t as high and will get his QB hit at times on the blitz which cannot happen. Late 1st round grade.

Joe Mixon, Oklahoma, #25

Game Film Evaluated:
Auburn (2016)
Ohio State (2016)
TCU (2016)

Summary: Elite level speed and quickness. Good stiff arm and able to out run angles with ease. Plus kickoff returner. Vision is plus who will totally abandon the play and cut to daylight. His ability to put foot in the ground and explode into the secondary is rare. He is one of the most comfortable receiving backs in the class. His ability to catch and run with speed and physicality is scary. He gives solid effort as a pass protector, needs to improve his footwork to anchor against bigger players who try to bull rush him. Joe Mixon the player is the most complete back in the class who brings elite speed, quickness, physical style, vision and pass receiving ability. His pass protection is above average but he can get the job done. However Mixon’s history makes his draft grade more complex. He was suspended in 2014 for the incident but never apologized until after the video was released.  The school Oklahoma is responsible for not doing the right thing and kicking him off the team after the incident. Mixon did not impress during subsequent interviews regarding the incident which suggest he has not learned his lesson and could happen again. The player is an elite level prospect as a franchise type back but I fear he will get into trouble multiple times as a pro. 4th round grade as his character gives me serious cause for concern but there is no denying the player’s ability is worthy of a top 10 elite level grade.

Christian McCaffrey, Stanford, #5

Game Film Evaluated:
USC (2016)
Washington (2016)
Kansas State (2016)

Summary: Fumbled vs USC. Elite receiving threat, he can run plus routes even setting up defenders on double moves. He has top level quickness. He returns kicks and punts. Patient runner who can run inside, side step tackles and run away from defenders but doesn’t play with top long speed. Struggles to break tackles. Excellent vision and his ability to know when to let the blocks develop and when to turn it on is good. Christian McCaffrey is a solid versatile type back who can contribute in the run and passing game with ease. He projects well to many spread pass first offenses that want their back to get involved in the passing game like the Patriots and Cardinals. He is a solid runner but he will change a game as a receiver more than anything. I don’t see elite level upside for him as a runner, there isn’t the balance or tackle breaking ability to suggest he is a top runner in the league. However he will consistently generate 130 to 150 yards of total offense per game with his ability to catch the ball and make something happen after he catches it.  The return game is impressive but I doubt coaches will let him do that for a top prospect. First round grade but not elite back.

Leonard Fournette, LSU, #7

Game Film Evaluated:
Wisconsin (2016)
Alabama (2016)
Auburn (2016)

Summary: He was brought down too easily in 2017, one defender should not be able to bring him down with that frame, size and speed. He also ran with inconsistent burst brought down from behind when trying to turn the corner. He can dominate the secondary when he gets past the second level of a defense. Comfortable running from traditional power I formations. His vision inside is plus and can really make it through tiny holes. He ran heavy in 2017, needs to cut weight to add that elite burst again to his game he showed earlier in his career. Leonard Fournette was not an elite player in 2017, anyone drafting him you are hoping to get more of the 2015 or 2016 version. I think he needs to shed 15 pounds to play at 225 to add that elite burst that the country drooled over as a freshman. That athleticism was not on that same level after September in 2017. He is not a solid pass protector, he has work to do there to earn the trust of his QB, technique and footwork.  He is not a solid receiver either, catching the ball in traffic was a struggle. He is a 2nd round grade based on 2017 film but people are hoping to hit a franchise back if he show he’s healthy and shows that athleticism we saw his first two years at LSU. He needs to go a team that doesn’t ask their backs to get involved in the passing game nor a QB to protect a significant amount of time. 2nd round grade.

Samaje Perine, Oklahoma, #32

Game Film Evaluated:
Baylor (2016)
Auburn (2016)

Summary: Solid inside one cut type runner. He brings a physical edge to the run game. He can lower the shoulder and push the pile forward. He has good burst and can break into the open field with an extra gear. May not have the long speed to take it the distance. Hesitant runner. Does not trust that the hole will be there and just bust it up inside. He waits for the hole to open and by the time he gets there, its closed. Samaje Perine looks like a rotational inside physical runner who can get some tough yards and an adequate receiver. He did not see many instances as a traditional pass protector of his QB thanks to the offense. Not a dynamic player who needs to improve his ability to read blocks, trust his lineman and just put a foot in the ground to go upfield. 5th round grade.

Alvin Kamara, Tennessee, #6

Game Film Evaluated:
Alabama (2016)
Georgia (2016)
Kentucky (2016)

Summary: Versatile athlete who has good speed. Upright running style who can line up all over the formation getting the ball in the backfield, shifting out to the slot and catch passes or line up exclusively as a receiver and run underneath routes. Not a dynamic player with the ball in his hands. He is a versatile player who can contribute in many ways but nothing is overly explosive or playmaking to his game. Alvin Kamara has upside and can be a better pro than college player especially if he finds his way to an offense that ask their backs to contribute just as much a receiver as a runner like the Patriots. He needs to run better inside the tackles, breaking tackles and setting up his blocks. 4th round grade.

Corey Clement, Wisconsin, #6

Game Film Evaluated:
LSU (2016)
Penn State (2016)
Michigan (2016)

Summary: Tremendous burst. Needs to run with a bit more patience when running inside especially with a FB. Good effort as a pass protector and shows good awareness to move around in the pocket to find the blitzer. Dropped catchable pass out of the backfield. Doesn’t break many tackles even when one on one with a defender. Fumbled twice vs Penn State and did not keep bowl high and tight. He has good vision at best when he makes one cut and goes upfield. He has good lateral quickness and can side step out of tackles and juke out defenders. Corey Clement is another one of the complete back prospects who adds a quality speed element to his game. He fits best for a zone blocking team that can allow him to become a one cut runner, use his good vision to feel where the hole is going to be. He is not a dynamic runner who can make something out of nothing, he will go as far as his line takes him. Late 3rd round grade.

Jeremy McNichols, Boise State, #13

Game Film Evaluated:
Washington State (2016)
BYU (2016)
UNLV (2016)

Summary: Shorter back with thick lower body and excellent balance with low center of gravity. He absorbs contact and keeps moving forward. He breaks tackles with good stiff arm and simply bouncing off tacklers. He has some burst but isn’t elite speed or quickness. Gives good effort as blocker and shows plus footwork to handle rushers. Adequate receiver. Struggles to get to the outside consistently, not a back you want to see running laterally. He needs to stay within the tackles to be successful. Physical back near the goaline who will fight for every yard. Needs to keep both hands on the ball when fighting for extra yards, he will fumble on occasion when engaged with defenders trying to get more yards. Jeremy McNichols is a physical between the tackles type runner who lacks great speed or elite quickness. He brings good balance and will break tackles. He is best working with a FB and reading blocks off that. He can protect his QB effectively and will catch passes. He is a complete back prospect but is not a fit for every scheme. Teams that want home run ability should look elsewhere but power running teams such as Seattle would be a good fit. 3rd round grade.

Kareem Hunt, Toledo, #3

Game Film Evaluated:
BYU (2016)
Northern Illinois (2016)

Summary: Super quick runner who is able to run inside. Gives good effort and can get the job done in pass protection. Solid receiver who can shake the defender and make a bigger play out of a check down pass. He can find the hole and explode to daylight through the smallest of places. He needs to become more decisive as a runner, one cut and go. He struggles when he tries to do too much and gets caught up. He loses all speed when he tries to change directions laterally. Runs with excellent balance and can take hits and keep moving after contact. Kareem Hunt is a good runner who can start in the NFL as one of the more complete backs. He can catch the ball and make an impact play, he can run inside and outside with speed to get away from defenders and break tackles. He is an average pass protector but gives the effort to suggest he can improve in that area. He is more quick than fast but it projects well for him to run in any type of offense but I would like to see him best as a one cut type runner who can use the cutback against the grain. 3rd round grade.

Brian Hill, Wyoming, #5

Game Film Evaluated:
BYU (2016)
Nebraska (2016)
New Mexico (2016)

Summary: Above average in pass protection. Comfortable running the ball from a traditional offense, I formation and single back. He will not go down easily, he will fight for extra yards. Not overly quick changing directions, he cannot afford to dance too much cuz he can’t restart the jets and get to full speed quickly enough. His vision is sub par, misses opportunities for bigger gains and runs into contact. Brian Hill has some upside to contribute on offense at the next level. His ability to protect the QB will keep on the field and has some good running ability, he showed a good stiff arm on film and has good speed to make plays downfield. Not a dynamic runner who can make something out of nothing but he gets the job done. Needs to improve his hands to become a realiable threat out of the backfield but he earn a job and be active on game day as a backup RB. 4th round grade.

Wayne Gallman, Clemson, #9

Game Film Evaluated:
Florida State (2016)
South Carolina (2016)
Alabama (2016)

Summary: Doesn’t break tackles, runs exclusively out of shotgun. Poor technique in pass protection. He looks to lower the shoulder to take on rushers but doesn’t properly square himself to get in position to absorb that contact. He can either take it or gets blown up instead of just doing his job effectively. Solid receiver out of the backfield and good jump cut runner. Physical runner who won’t quit after contact especially near the goaline. Wayne Gallman has some ability has a receiving option back with good speed and adds a short yardage physical type. He doesn’t look like someone who can a majority carry guy nor someone to be a feature back. 5th round grade.

Marlon Mack, South Florida, #5

Game Film Evaluated:
Florida State (2016)
East Carolina (2016)
UConn (2016)

Summary: Left the FSU game with an apparent head injury. Fumbled vs East Carolina. Good jump cut runner. Too much dancing in the backfield. He can cut with speed and jump his way through traffic. He doesn’t lose much speed when making moves. He has an extra gear in daylight and will outrun angles. Almost fumbled again vs UConn. He is a bit player, used as outside option on speed plays. Lines up frequently as a receiver to be used on screens and occassionally sent on go routes to use his speed but he doesn’t track the ball like a receiver. Prefers to run outside, not comfortable inside nor breaking tackles.Virtually no experience as a pass protector and not powerful when he leads on run plays. He projects to be a backup 3rd down option who has athleticism that can make him useful in situational plays. 5th round grade.

Joe Williams, Utah, #28

Game Film Evaluated:
UCLA (2016)
Washington (2016)
BYU (2016)

Summary: Not comfortable catching the ball. Fumbled against BYU and he gets run over in pass protection. Upright running style and takes a lot of hard hits as a result. He’s got good burst and extra gear in the open field to take it the distance. Not a tackle breaker. He does not shy away from contact at all. The definition of the back that hits the hole hard. Joe Williams is a speed back who runs physical inside and doesn’t shy away from the tough yards inside and hitting the hole hard. His upright running style is a concern for durability and he did fumble against BYU. He isn’t a good pass protector nor is he a consistent option as a receiver either. His speed and ability to run physical suggest he can be a rotational piece back to spell the starter. He needs to bring that athleticism and physical edge to special teams to solidify his roster spot. There are concerns whether he really wants to play football. He was suspended while at UConn for credit card theft and illegal use. He then retired in 2016 at Utah but decided to rejoin the team when injuries hit the team. 4th round ability but ends up with a 6th round grade due to off the field concerns.

Tarik Cohen, North Carolina A&T, #28

Game Film Evaluated:
Kent State (2016)
Alcorn State (2015)

Summary: Severely undersized but extremely quick and shifty. He has good long speed but he is much quicker than fast. He is a comfortable receiver and able to run routes out of the backfield and when shifted out of the backfield to the slot position. He did fumble vs Kent State and struggles to break tackles when running inside. He brings some physical running to his game, he will fight for extra yards which is what lead to the fumble. He was not observed in pass protection but his size suggest it will be a challenge at any level. Tarik Cohen is an ideal 3rd down type back granted you do not ask him to do a lot of blitz pick up. He is someone you put into the game to take advantage of blitzes and man coverage, he will not be brought down 1 on 1 in space in the NFL. He fits best as a speed back that gets the ball in space running outside on zone read type plays and split out wide as a receiver like the Houston Texans do. Not in the same class as Darren Sproles since he isn’t as good a inside runner nor someone who can break tackles. 5th round grade.

James Conner, Pittsburgh, #24

Game Film Evaluated:
Penn State (2016)
North Carolina (2016)
Virginia Tech (2016)

Summary: Team captain, emotional leader. Physical inside runner, he will break a lot of tackles and be one of the leaders in yards after contact. Runs with excellent balance and built low to ground. Lot of power in his legs and he drives through contact. He is a adequate receiver out of the backfield and he has enough burst to get to the second level of a defense. He will have trouble getting outside consistently at the next level. He lacks the explosive burst nor someone who is at his best in a zone blocking scheme, he thrives on inside power runs reading the blocks of his lineman and working through traffic. He fumbled against Penn State. He takes pass protection seriously and looks to punish defenders. James Conner is a highly physical emotional inside runner that reminds me of Marion Barber III when he came out of Minnesota. Conner breaks a lot of tackles and consistently keeps the feet moving when engaged with defenders. He has adequate burst to get to the secondary of a defense but lacks the long speed to give the home run threat. He projects best to an angle blocking scheme that prefers to run the ball physical and between the tackles like the Steelers and Cowboys. Good player who lacks the upside of others in the class but he is a better polished and more physical runner.  He may not have a long career due to the running style but he will be productive for aslong as his body allows him to. Late 3rd round grade.

Matthew Dayes, North Carolina State, #21

Game Film Evaluated:
Clemson (2016)
Florida State (2016)
North Carolina (2016)

Summary: Good burst, protects the ball effectively. Capable receiver and he can protect the QB in blitz. He is a physical inside one cut runner. He is a effective jump cut runner, good juke move. Able to put his foot in the ground and cut it upfield with good burst. He is not comfortable running inside between the tackles using vision and breaking tackles inside. He is a one cut runner who excels in a zone scheme on stretch plays to read the hole and cut it upfield if necessary. Matthew Dayes is a solid 3 down back who has good speed, ability to catch passes and above average in pass protection. He is not a strong tackle breaker or comfortable as a inside runner. He is best as a one cut runner who can feel for the hole and cut it back against the grain to run to daylight. He projects as a solid second string back who is more than capable to play in any situation but will never be a plus starter in the NFL. He will get you the yards available and execute his job whether protecting the QB or catching the ball. 5th round grade.

T.J. Logan, North Carolina, #8

Game Film Evaluated:
Florida State (2016)
Virginia (2016)

Summary: Patient runner and then explodes to daylight. Good hands to make the difficult catch. Fumbled vs Virginia but he consistently puts 2 hands over the ball when running inside and keeps it high and tight others. Don’t project fumbling to be a problem for him in the future. He has a good feel for knowing when to turn on the speed and when to let the hole open up. Above average blocker, he can set his feet and absorb the rush and stand them up. He is a step slow to recognize the hole and can run up his blockers mostly when running outside the tackles. He is at his best as a one cut runner and using the cut back. He is not a big tackle breaker, he out runs angles and can accelerate away from defenders. TJ Logan may never be a starter but he is a for sure quality back in a rotation that has the speed to make defenders pay attention, versatile to be used as a receiver and reliable in pass protection. 3rd round grade.

D’Onta Foreman, Texas, #33

Game Film Evaluated:
West Virginia (2016)
TCU (2016)
Kansas State (2016)

Summary: Bigger physical inside runner. He has a burst in the open field but it takes him a bit to get to full speed. He can run away from defenders if he gets some space. He runs up the back of his lineman, not someone who is comfortable to bounce the run outside and able to turn the corner effectively. He is a volume runner, needs a lot of carries and eventually will have a longer run but play in and out there is not a lot of quality runs. Average pass protector and he can catch the ball but will drop passes at times. Not someone who can make the difficult catch. He has to be a one cut and decisive runner, he will be taken down for losses if he dances in the backfield too much. D’Onta Foreman is a quality inside physical runner. He has a good extra gear to run away from defenders if he gets some space. He is not a dynamic runner who can bounce it outside and shake defenders at the next level. He lacks the vision to run to daylight, too often he runs up the backs of his lineman. He needs to improve his pass protection, keep his head on a swivel to find the blitzer to not get his QB killed. He can be a second string runner who brings good size and speed who can be a solid inside runner. 5th round grade.

FULLBACKS

Sam Rogers, Virginia Tech, #45

Game Film Evaluated:
Tennessee (2016)
Boston College (2016)


Summary: Versatile type fullback. He lines up in space and able to hit the moving target on the outside. Not a physical or powerful blocker at the POA or able to knock his man downfield and out of the hole. He is a physical runner able to generate yards after contact. Catches the ball effectively. Sam Rogers is a below average blocker but has some skills as a receiver and runner. He was not used as a traditional fullback in a running formation behind the QB and he is not comfortable taking on defenders in traffic and knocking them out of the hole. 6th round grade.